Dongjin Lee, False Advertisement, Induced Mistake, and Tortious Liability, THE JOURNAL OF PROPERTY LAW, Vol 35, No.4(2019), pp. 31-63.
<Abstract>
The Korean Supreme Court denies the buyer of a condominium the right to rescind the sales contract even when the buyer mistook some factors important for the contract and the seller’s negligent or innocent misrepresentation, especially seller’s false advertisement, induced the mistake, on the reason that it is a mistake on motive. Instead, it has granted the buyer a tortious claim for damages, the amount of which is assessed by the gap between the contract price and the hypothetical just price considering the falsehood of the advertisement. In a recent case rendered on July 23. 2015, the Korean Supreme Court ruled that the damages cannot be claimed any more when the seller rescinded the contract and, more importantly, not the assignee of the sales contract but the assignor, the original buyer, can sue for damages when the sales contract was assumed by another. The former ruling is agreeable, and more importantly, shows that the tortious damages in this case is in fact a disguised form of contractual adjustment. In addition, it would be shown that the mistake defense should have been allowed in this case if it were not a case of the condominium sale which entailed various types of risks the buyer should bear. A total rescission of the contract cannot be allowed here because otherwise the mistaken party would have an opportunity to exempt oneself from the losing contract. Lastly, it also reveals the reason why the latter ruling is flawed.
<Keywords>
mistake on motive, misrepresentation, advertisement, losing contract, contractual adjustment, assignment of contract
Dongjin Lee, False Advertisement, Induced Mistake, and Tortious Liability, THE JOURNAL OF PROPERTY LAW, Vol 35, No.4(2019), pp. 31-63.
<Abstract>
The Korean Supreme Court denies the buyer of a condominium the right to rescind the sales contract even when the buyer mistook some factors important for the contract and the seller’s negligent or innocent misrepresentation, especially seller’s false advertisement, induced the mistake, on the reason that it is a mistake on motive. Instead, it has granted the buyer a tortious claim for damages, the amount of which is assessed by the gap between the contract price and the hypothetical just price considering the falsehood of the advertisement. In a recent case rendered on July 23. 2015, the Korean Supreme Court ruled that the damages cannot be claimed any more when the seller rescinded the contract and, more importantly, not the assignee of the sales contract but the assignor, the original buyer, can sue for damages when the sales contract was assumed by another. The former ruling is agreeable, and more importantly, shows that the tortious damages in this case is in fact a disguised form of contractual adjustment. In addition, it would be shown that the mistake defense should have been allowed in this case if it were not a case of the condominium sale which entailed various types of risks the buyer should bear. A total rescission of the contract cannot be allowed here because otherwise the mistaken party would have an opportunity to exempt oneself from the losing contract. Lastly, it also reveals the reason why the latter ruling is flawed.
<Keywords>
mistake on motive, misrepresentation, advertisement, losing contract, contractual adjustment, assignment of contract